Home/Blog/Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin-Williams
Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin-Williams: a painter's room-by-room answer
We buy both brands every week at our contractor discount and roll them onto Massachusetts and New Hampshire walls. Here is what actually differs in Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin-Williams, which line to pick for each room, and why the product line matters more than the name on the can.
By Fine Coat Painters, Burlington, MA · Updated November 16, 2026


Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin-Williams in five lines
- 1
It is a tie at the top. Aura and Emerald are both excellent; most homeowners could not tell them apart on a wall.
- 2
Compare lines, not brands. A brand's entry paint is a different product from its flagship. Always name the line.
- 3
Where you buy differs. Sherwin-Williams sells through its own stores; Benjamin Moore through independent local dealers.
- 4
Color is personal. Pick the color first, then use the brand it comes from, or sample the match. That alone settles most Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin-Williams questions.
- 5
Prep beats paint. A mid-line paint over good repairs and primer beats a top-line paint over a bad wall.
Fine Coat Painters is an owner-led company in Burlington, MA, rated 5.0 from 93 Google reviews. We use both brands, so we have no reason to push one in the Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin-Williams debate, and we write the exact product and sheen into every proposal.
Free painting estimate
We will spec the paint for each room.
Sherwin-Williams vs Benjamin Moore, matched product for product
The fair way to compare Sherwin-Williams vs Benjamin Moore is line against line. These are the pairs we price against each other when we write a proposal. Each row compares products made for the same job, at roughly the same tier, which is the only fair way to read a Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin-Williams comparison. Names change now and then; the brand websites have the current lineups (Benjamin Moore, Sherwin-Williams).
| Use | Benjamin Moore | Sherwin-Williams |
|---|---|---|
| Flagship interior | Aura | Emerald |
| Workhorse interior | Regal Select | Duration Home, SuperPaint |
| Budget interior | ben | Captivate, ProMar (contractor) |
| Trim, doors, cabinets | Advance (waterborne alkyd) | Emerald Urethane Trim Enamel, ProClassic |
| Ceilings | Waterborne Ceiling Paint | dedicated ceiling paints, e.g. Eminence |
| Flagship exterior | Aura Exterior | Emerald Exterior |
| Workhorse exterior | Regal Select Exterior | Duration Exterior, SuperPaint Exterior |
| Deck stain | Arborcoat | SuperDeck |
| Where it is sold | Independent paint and hardware dealers | Company-operated Sherwin-Williams stores |
Ring's End, a Benjamin Moore dealer, has a useful side-by-side of Aura and Regal Select (Ring's End). Read any single-brand dealer's comparison with that in mind.
Want premium paint without the store price? We pass our contractor discount on.
The best paint brand for interior walls, room by room
Pick a room or surface. The picker settles Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin-Williams for that room: it shows the lines and sheens we would put on it, and writes it into a note you can send with your estimate request or take to the store.
Room or surface
Sheen names vary a little between brands: Benjamin Moore calls its low-shine exterior finish "low lustre", Sherwin-Williams calls a similar finish "satin". Ask to see the actual chip.




Aura vs Emerald: when the flagship is worth it
Aura vs Emerald is the top of the Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin-Williams question: both are the most expensive interior paint each brand makes. In our experience they cover deep colors in fewer coats, touch up better and stand up to scrubbing.
- Spend on it forDeep, saturated colors; halls, kids' rooms and kitchens; any room you will wipe down often.
- Skip it forCeilings, closets, guest bedrooms and rental turnovers, where a good mid-line paint looks the same.
- HandlingBoth dry fast. On big walls we roll one full wall at a time to keep a wet edge; that matters more than which one you pick.
- Touch-upsFlagships blend touch-ups better, especially in matte, which is the practical reason to choose the top line when deciding Aura vs Emerald against a mid-line paint. Keep a labelled quart for each room.




Regal Select vs Duration: the paint most rooms actually get
Regal Select vs Duration is the comparison that matters for most homes. Most of the walls we paint get a mid-line paint, and for good reason: two coats over good prep give a finish that lasts for years.
- Regal SelectBenjamin Moore's long-time workhorse. Levels well and comes in a true matte that hides wall flaws.
- Duration Home and SuperPaintSherwin-Williams' equivalents. Easy to find at any company store and often on sale.
- Our defaultWhichever matches the client's color and is easiest to get on the day. Both get two finish coats.
- The real differenceThe color you choose and the prep under it, not the logo.
Can one brand match the other's color?
In Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin-Williams color matching, the answer is usually close, rarely perfect. Each brand mixes its own colors with its own tints, so a computer match from the other brand can lean warmer or cooler on the wall.
- BestUse the brand the color belongs to.
- GoodHave the match mixed, then paint a large sample next to the original chip, in morning and evening light.
- AvoidMixing brands on one wall. Touch-ups from a different brand often show.
Color help is free with every estimate. See our guides to interior paint colors and white paint colors.


Not sure which line your rooms need? We spec it at the free visit.


How contractor pricing changes the Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin-Williams math
Shelf prices differ, and Sherwin-Williams runs frequent sales at its company stores, which is why people often frame Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin-Williams as a price question. But a painting company does not pay shelf price for either brand.
- We buy both at a contractor discountand pass it on to you, so the premium brands cost you less through us than over the counter.
- Paint is a small part of the billMost of the cost of a painted room is labor and prep, so moving up a line adds less than people expect.
- Ask for the product nameEvery proposal should say the brand, the line and the sheen for each surface. Ours always does.
Room prices are in our interior painting cost guide.
The primer under it decides Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin-Williams more than the topcoat
Many Massachusetts homes have plaster, old oil-based trim, water stains or knotty wood. On those surfaces the primer does the hard work, and both brands make good ones.
- Old glossy trimA bonding primer, such as Benjamin Moore Fresh Start or Sherwin-Williams Extreme Bond, after cleaning and a light sanding, so new waterborne enamel grips.
- Stains and knotsA stain-blocking primer over water marks, smoke and wood tannin, or they bleed back through any topcoat.
- Patches and new drywallA drywall primer so the repair does not flash through the finish.
- Pre-1978 homesAny work that disturbs old paint follows Massachusetts lead-safe rules (Mass.gov).




So, Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin-Williams: which do we pick?
For most rooms in most houses, either. We choose by the color, the room and the surface, and we name the line in writing.
- If you love a Benjamin Moore colorWe use Benjamin Moore, usually Regal Select on walls and Advance on trim.
- If you love a Sherwin-Williams colorWe use Sherwin-Williams, usually Duration Home or SuperPaint on walls and Emerald Urethane on trim.
- If you have no preferenceWe pick the line that suits each room, and you get the contractor price either way.
- Either wayTwo finish coats, primer where it is needed, and repairs done first.
Exterior paint for Massachusetts and New Hampshire weather
Freeze-thaw winters, humid summers and strong sun on south walls are hard on paint. Outside is where the top lines earn their price, and where Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin-Williams matters least next to timing.
- Siding and trimAura Exterior or Emerald Exterior where the budget allows; Regal Select Exterior or Duration Exterior as the strong second choice.
- DecksArborcoat or SuperDeck, matched to how much shade the deck gets.
- Timing beats brandAny exterior paint fails if it goes on cold or damp. Our season runs about May to October; see the best time to paint in New Hampshire.

Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin-Williams: questions and answers
Is Benjamin Moore better than Sherwin-Williams?
Neither brand is better across the board. Their top lines, Aura and Emerald, are both excellent; their middle lines, Regal Select and Duration Home or SuperPaint, are close. The product line and sheen you choose matter more than the name on the can.
Which do professional painters use?
Both. Many painters keep a Sherwin-Williams contractor account because the stores are company-run and easy to find, and buy Benjamin Moore through local dealers for clients who want its colors or products. We use both.
Can you match a Benjamin Moore color in Sherwin-Williams paint?
Stores can computer-match a color across brands, and it is usually close. For a whole room we prefer to use the brand the color comes from, or to paint a large sample of the match first.
Is Aura worth it over Regal Select?
For deep colors, high-traffic halls and rooms you want to wipe often, the top line is worth it. For bedrooms and ceilings, a mid-line paint applied well over good prep looks the same.
Do you charge more for one brand?
We buy both at contractor pricing and pass the discount on, so the brand choice usually changes the total far less than people expect. The written proposal names the exact product and sheen.
What is the best paint brand for interior walls?
For most homes, the best paint brand for interior walls is the one that carries your color, in a good mid-line or top-line product. Benjamin Moore Regal Select or Aura and Sherwin-Williams Duration Home, SuperPaint or Emerald all qualify when the prep is right.
Is one brand lower in odor or VOCs?
Both brands make low-VOC and zero-VOC lines for bedrooms, nurseries and winter work with the windows closed. The odor difference between lines is bigger than the difference between brands, so ask for a low-odor line by name.
Does Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin-Williams change how long a paint job lasts?
Much less than prep, primer and application do. A top line from either brand, over sound repairs with two finish coats, will outlast any paint rolled over a dirty or glossy wall.
What do you use on ceilings?
A dedicated flat ceiling paint from either brand. Ceiling paints are made to spatter less and hide roller marks, which matters more than the brand overhead.
Get premium paint at our price, applied right
Tell us the rooms. Whatever you decide on Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin-Williams, at the free visit we help with color, name the exact Benjamin Moore or Sherwin-Williams product for each surface, and give you one written price. We paint across Massachusetts and southern New Hampshire.

Get my free estimate
Free visit, one written price.